
Among the London Planes
Finding the right sculpture for Dad.
In the months before my father died, he’d ask my siblings and me to wheel him around the park next door to his Philadelphia high rise. As we pushed, he’d point at the London Plane trees that dotted the park, exclaiming: “Oh, aren’t they beautiful!” Not really, I’d think. The London Plane, as its name suggests, is a somewhat plain variety — its branches are gnarled and twisty, its bark mottled and peeling. Some of them, in this park at least, are two centuries old.
That my dad should get so much joy from a bunch of old trees was itself sur prising. He’d always been gruff, quick to anger. But in his declining years, a childmy daughter bouncing happily on a bar stool sipping Shirley Temples while I chatted with the bartender. The local dry cleaner, always perched on her stool by the window, would greet me with a wave and say hello every morning, offering pretzels from her big jar. No tear in the fabric of any stuffed animal was beyond her ministering art. And then there was the meatball sandwich with pickles at Court Street Grocers.
Almost imperceptibly, thin tendrils of connection were forming around me.
I don’t remember exactly when, but at some point I noticed that neither of us was asking anymore “What do we do now?”
When people sit shiva, they are instructed not to ask mourners “How are you?” or “What can I do?” They are not there to talk the mourner out of their grief; they are there to remind them -with their very presence — that normalcy will return, that life will go on. That’s what the neighborhood was doing for me, long before I had words for it.
Fifteen years after moving in, I have friends down the hall, a book club in my building; a neighborhood group of women who get together every Monday for a game of Mahjong; and, best of all, a group of single moms I celebrate holidays with. My first daughter, and a second one who came a decade later, have developed their micro-communities here, too. But rich as those things are, it’s not the intentional community I’ve created that makes me feel less alone when bad things happen. It’s the acci dental community, the people around me from whom I ask nothing and who ask nothing of me besides a little everyday kindness.
I will never have anonymity in these few square blocks inside Carroll Gar dens. What I have instead is something I couldn’t have planned and wouldn’t have believed possible: a place — a life like wonder and delight had re-emerged.
When my new girlfriend visited the apartment for the first time, he grasped her hand in his and kissed it like a knight in a fairy tale. Even after he’d begun to forget the names of his grandkids, he’d relish every scrap of news about them.
“Isn’t that something,” he’d say, smiling from ear to ear.
After my dad finally passed, my mother was bereft. That too was something of a surprise. Though they’d weathered the storms, their marriage had been far from idyllic. In those last few years, she’d become his nursemaid — an exhausting and unrewarding job. Many of us expected her to be relieved when he died. Instead, we’d catch her sitting alone among the law books in his office, sobbing.
One day she announced that she wanted to commission a sculpture of a London Plane tree to sit in the corner of her apartment. It has to be big, she said, at least 6’ tall. And she didn’t want some abstraction or artist’s interpretation; she wanted the real thing. I was tasked with finding a sculptor.
I logged on to Etsy and began flicking through pages. I found a woman in Ire land who made ersatz bonsai trees out of wire, and a guy in Texas who crafted perfect two inch replicas of cotton woods for toy train sets.
Finally I came to a site called “The Sculptured Mood” featuring photos of enormous fake trees set in gleaming hotel lobbies and wedding venues. Perfect Jap anese red maples made from silk and clay; exact dogwoods down to the white bark. I noticed there were only a handful of reviews, but they were all five stars.
Maybe, I told myself, the Sculptured Mood was new to Etsy. I filled out a form and hit send and soon heard back from a woman named Sophie. Sure, Sophie said, we can make a London Plane tree for you.
The next day, I hiked up to the Con cert Grove in Prospect Park to take pho tos of a stand of London Planes. I sent the pictures to Sophie. A few weeks later she sent back an artist’s rendering of the sculpture. This has to be a joke, I thought.
It looked more like a coat rack than a tree.
I drafted a response and shared it with my mother. “I wish I could say this is what we talked about, but it just isn’t. Compare the photos I sent of the trees — with elegant, arcing branches and a solid trunk — with your rendering, which looks gnarled and like a bush that’s lost its leaves.” “Drop criticism of gnarled,” mom texted back tersely. “Gnarled is good. Don’t suggest leaves. I don’t trust that.”
I sent Sophie the text and waited.
It’s hard to know what to make of my dad’s fondness for his London Plane trees. Maybe it was their name — he was an anglophile of the first order. Or maybe it was their seeming permanence at a time when he felt his impermanence so acutely. It was much easier to suss out mom’s singular focus. Her pursuit of the perfect replica was a way to express her devotion. It was a way to ease into this new life without him.
We never did get the sculpture. After foot fake tree in the corner of her small apartment.
At 92, mom still takes daily walks.
From the window of her 36th floor apart ment, you can see her down below, a tiny figure making slow circles around the park, walking among the London Planes. a few rounds of back and forth, Sophie went silent. Turns out you shouldn’t pick a tree sculptor on Etsy, espe cially not one with four reviews who insists on full payment upfront.
But it hardly mattered.
The site refunded our money, and perhaps it is for the best that mom doesn’t have a 6 Here is where the second one goes.
In the months before my father died, he’d ask my siblings and me to wheel him around the park next door to his Philadel phia high rise. As we pushed, he’d point at the London Plane trees that dotted the park, exclaiming: “Oh, aren’t they beau tiful!” Not really, I’d think. The London Plane, as its name suggests, is a somewhat plain variety — its branches are gnarled and twisty, its bark mottled and peeling.
Some of them, in this park at least, are two centuries old.
I logged on to Etsy and began flick ing through pages. I found a woman in Ireland who made ersatz bonsai trees out of wire, and a guy in Texas who crafted perfect two inch replicas of cottonwoods for toy train sets. Finally I came to a site called “The Sculptured Mood” featur ing photos of enormous fake trees set in gleaming hotel lobbies and wedding venues. Perfect Japanese red maples made from silk and clay; exact dogwoods down to the white bark. I noticed there were only a handful of reviews, but they were all five stars. Maybe, I told myself, the Sculptured Mood was new to Etsy. I filled out a form and hit send and soon heard back from a woman named Sophie.
Sure, Sophie said, we can make a London Plane tree for you.
We never did get the sculpture. After a few rounds of back and forth, Sophie went silent. Turns out you shouldn’t pick a tree sculptor on Etsy, especially not one with four reviews who insists on full pay ment upfront. But it hardly mattered. The site refunded our money, and perhaps it is for the best that mom doesn’t have a 6 foot fake tree in the corner of her small apartment.